The Lane Kiffin Effect: If It Works Out Like A Duck...
You have to give Lane Kiffin this much: people don't waste much time forming opinions about him. After a brief phase of uncertainty, we fans seem to be downright giddy about him. Likewise, each recruit he visits is surprisingly impressed with him and his staff. And not to be outdone, the current players have their views on the new wunderkind as well.
Brothers in Arms
To spoil the ending, silence is golden. Since arriving on the scene, Lane Kiffin has turned everything upside-down on the players. Gone are the days where seniority mattered; now, no player has a starting job. (Not even Eric Berry.) The rules of the weight room have changed. Lane has also been known to attend 5:30 AM workouts to check up on the progress of the players - in January. He has also checked in on classes - unannounced - to see if the players were actually there. (Side note: what do you think would have happened if Berry had decided to skip his 8AM that day?)
Yet there haven't been much in the way of grumblings. I hadn't heard anything about the early practices until Kiffin mentioned them in an interview (and that as a side comment to help explain a different point). The rules are completely different from the "family" that they had grown into during the Fulmer era, yet it hasn't caused mass rioting. At least not on any scale that's made the news.
Lame Ducks
The bad is epitomized quickly, and in the exception to the general rule seen in Brothers in Arms. As we already know, E.J. Abrams-Ward and Ramone Johnson are gone from the team - early departures who apparently were not seen as the compete-in-everything-including-academics-and-offseason-workouts types that Kiffin wants. The details haven't been released; really, we don't need to know the details, but the fact stands that whatever the threshold is for success as a UT football player under Kiffin, not every incumbent automatically qualifies.
Kiffin, in an interview earlier this month, mentioned that he doesn't believe in dismissing a couple of players "to set examples", and I am willing to believe him on that point. First, it's a horrid policy, as it risks making unwarranted dismissals and creates a very negative atmosphere. Second, that's a practice that has never been used by any of his mentors - from his own dad through Pete Carroll. If Kiffin were one to make such moves, it would have been from a personality flaw, and I don't think Hamilton would have taken such a gamble on a 34-year old with temper issues.
But with any coaching change, there is a risk of washout in the transition. Even in a switch as mild as the expected Bowden-Fisher hand-me-down, every new head coach will have a different approach. What was once the norm might not exist, and you don't always know how people will respond. Will we see more dismissals between now and the start of the season? Quite likely, actually. There's a lot of time between now and the next season which means there'll be a lot of time for second-guessing and frustration to take their toll.
Intermission
Then again, there's a lot of time for the new football family to grow and develop. Of all the effects Lane Kiffin has had, this is the one we'll have to wait to see. Will the players "buy in" quickly, or will there be extended growing pains? We just don't know.
So we wait. Fortunately, the wait isn't a pure vacuum. We have National Signing Day coming up next Tuesday. We have the Orange and White game coming up (I'll be there, $5 in hand!). Prior to the O&W, the spring scrimmages should be loaded with news as every beat sports reporter is going to be prowling for good material. And with a staff as colorful in character as this staff, you can be assured that quotable material is right around the corner.
1 recs |
5 comments
|
Comments
i believe
Kiffin is going to do a good job we might have an off year this year but thats fine we have a top of the line coaching staff if i had a kid which i dont im only 19 that was getting ready to play some football in college and wanted to go pro i would send him to tennessee im very excited about Tennessee football this year and i cant wait till the season starts
rOcKaMaNia2o09
by rOcKaMaNiA2009 on Jan 30, 2009 11:22 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
i know it's almost preposterous to suggest
but people need to keep expectations in check this coming year.
remember, that was one hell of a sinking, broken, wrecked ship on offense last year. it might take therapy to fully recover from the clawfense. defense should be nasty as always, but it could take a few years for the right talent to accumulate on offense.
running usc’s offense is nice if you have the dominating player-by-player advantage that usc is used to having. however, as i saw first hand with the titans and norm chow, when you put usc’s offense on a more even playing field talent-wise it kinda sucks. when the titans had a developing qb, plodding running backs and mediocre receivers, it failed miserably. when carson palmer, mike williams, or reggie bush are running it against the pac-10 circa 2004, it looks unstoppable.
i am still concerned as to how our offense is going to look if lane is really in the driver’s seat, at least until he and coach o get a few recruiting classes in, that is.
The Official Enforcer of MCM
by hal41605 on Jan 30, 2009 11:57 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
On Chow in Tennessee...
Chow from what I understand, (correct me if I’m wrong) was also a little bit handcuffed by Jeff Fisher. It just wasn’t a good combination. I bet deep down Fisher would love to just run the single wing play good defense and win 6-0 every week. Chow has a little more imagination.
My only hope for the offense is that its not something that requires a brain surgeon to decipher, I think we had solid personnel in 2008 and will have it as well 2009 but they need to be running a system that they can execute with confidence.
by Getoffmyvols on Jan 30, 2009 12:32 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
some truth to this
i think one of the biggest problems was that it was a chow-type offense with fisher-type personnel.
it’s really tough to tell how fisher and chow worked together. you have to think, with his usc pedigree, that fisher knew who he was going after when he picked chow. i can’t imagine he brought in a guy from his alma mater so that he could handcuff him. but the fit was always uncomfortable, that much is totally true.
The Official Enforcer of MCM
by hal41605 on Jan 30, 2009 2:20 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs

by 













