Allow Me to Reiterate...
Bumped from the FanPosts. Great job by VolnVA.
-- Joel
I do feel a bit as though I am beating a dead horse here as it has already been 48+ hours since the game ended, but I just got back home this evening from Birmingham after going to the game on Saturday. I just wanted to share a few observations and leave a few questions about 'Bama before refocusing on SCarolina.
I think I have been able to gain enough perspective now to admit that it was a highly entertaining game. I had a feeling all week that Tennessee was certainly capable of pulling the upset, but my rational brain thought that Alabama would win by 10-14. Their body of work to date is more impressive than any other team I've had the opportunity to watch this season, and other than the throttling of UGA, I think we can all admit that the Vols haven't garnered too many results thus far.
As the game unfolded, I continued to believe UT could win, but it looked more and more like UA would pull away. I felt it come close to getting away at the end of the first half, then I felt it slipping again at the end of the 4th quarter. Before it got out of control, though, the defense came up huge (as they are wont to do) and 3+ of the most exciting minutes I have ever witnessed unfolded, ultimately coming up 4 seconds short of being the BEST 3+ minutes I think I have ever witnessed. Those last few minutes just truly encompassed everything that makes college football so spectacular on a weekly basis.
Before I ramble too much (and perhaps I have already crossed that threshold...), below are my observations and outstanding questions to put to rest before I can truly move on to the Gamecocks.
- I was very proud of my guys...and I was extremely devastated by the final outcome. In my opinion, the most dangerous thing for a sports fan is hope. I was ready to embrace defeat with 3.5 minutes to go, but there the Vols went clawing, scratching, and making things happen. I felt that I was about to be part of something special, something that you could really tell the kids/grandkids about one day, "Yes, I was there when UT scored 10 in the last 2 minutes to destroy an undefeated Alabama team's dreams." Then a series of unfortunate events happened...and I couldn't believe it. I was on the last row of the upper deck and had to resist the urge to jump overboard, ultimately settling for collapsing in a heap on the ground. My girlfriend said she was afraid I was never going to get up. I am encouraged that we are competitive again...but that loss hurt...a lot.
- Jonathan Crompton deserves better. I'll confess to being a bit fair weather when it comes to Crompton. I was ready to throw him under the bus after the UCLA game. But if you look at all the crap he has had to deal with over the last season and a half and then consider his last 9 quarters, I am amazed. He has played with poise and confidence since the end of the Auburn game and I no longer dread every time that he drops back to throw. As has been mentioned in several other posts, this had a chance to be his vindication, his redemption...I wish it had happened for him.
- Our defense is beastly. It's not just EB. It's Janzen Jackson. It's Dennis Rogan. It's Rico McCoy (speaking of which, is there an injury update on him? I didn't notice while being at the game, but I caught the 2nd half of the replay on CSS last night and took notice when they said he was out with an undisclosed injury). It's Monte being smarter than everybody. I obviously want EB back next year, but we can continue to be strong on that side of the ball without him.
- Penalties hurt us...badly. We've all gone back and forth on the fat man's helmet at the end of the game ad nauseam (thanks, PTI). I'm not suggesting we got screwed by the refs in one way or another over the course of the game (because it's really hard to tell these things from the last row of the stadium), but we had some real drive killers. Those 2 long 2nd half drives that ended up with no points were seriously hampered by penalties. Whether it was a lack of discipline or just being physically outmanned at some spots, we've got to clean that up for next week.
- This is the one that really feels talked out, but the last 45 seconds were not well managed. Obviously you don't want to get that close and throw an interception trying to get 5 more yards. I understand that. But given the way we had been destroyed on the previous 40+ yard attempt (it hit Cody in the armpit it was so low), didn't it make sense to get closer? If Lincoln's quad really was bothering him and he's struggling to get the right combination of height and distance, doesn't it help him to be 7-10 yards closer in the middle of the field? Again, it's been well-documented that an extra point wouldn't have made it against the absolute jailbreak that occurred, but I'm not sure Lane put Lincoln in the best position for success.
- Did anyone else notice commentary on how 'Bama "dominated" the game until the last 3 minutes? Between the AP write up of the game, a couple of Saban's post-game comments, Pat Forde's article, and some things in the Birmingham paper, I became convinced they watched a different game than I did. Alabama controlled the 1st half, but UT owned them in the 2nd. I just found it strange they would essentially ignore the entire 2nd half of the game...
- None of the other coaches in the SEC want to give Kiffin credit for anything. I know he came in with guns blazing and aimed barbs specifically at Meyer, Saban, and Spurrier. I find it odd, however, that both Meyer and Saban have blamed extenuating circumstances (the Great Flu Outbreak of 2009, i.e.) or conservative play calling (don't you guys have control over that?) rather than giving some credit to Lane & Co. Maybe he's in their heads, maybe they fear the recruiting behemoth if they say anything positive, maybe they don't like that he's taken the same group of guys and made them a lot better. Maybe they don't like that our defense has made them look extremely vulnerable. Whatever it is, it strikes me as odd.
- Let's be clear...I really don't like Alabama, but dangit if I don't respect them. I think Saban is a money-grubbing opportunist. I find their band with their little capes incredibly irritating. Rammer Jammer instills in me a tremendous desire to pop somebody in the face (I know you can't change the lyrics on the fly, but c'mon, 12-10 does not a "hell beating" make). Their drunk/obnoxious fans are just as bad as anybody else's drunk/obnoxious fans. But I don't know of any other place where fans would seek out supporters of their rival, pat them on the back, shake their hand, and say, "Your team played a great game today." Maybe they were saying this to all UT fans, maybe they just said it to me because I looked more despondent than anyone else. I have been to 4 games in Alabama (last one in B-ham, 3 in Tuscaloosa) and I have enjoyed them all. The majority of that crowd knows class.
- I have a funny feeling that this was Alabama's Clint Stoerner moment. I, like probably all of you, have many vivid memories of the 1998 season. Tennessee had no business beating Syracuse on Donovan McNabb's personal field day, but they did. Tennessee had no business beating Florida minus one bad dude named Al Wilson. Tennessee had no business coming back and ultimately pulling out a miracle against an 8-0 Arkansas team that had a huge lead. Sometimes, things just go your way on the way to the ultimate prize. If anybody's taking notes, I am calling Alabama winning the NC in 2.5 months. It is their year.
That was a lot to say...but I had to finish the cathartic process by writing this all down. I am now ready to move on to a HUUUUUUUUUGE game against South Carolina. 8-4 is still a legitimate goal, but 6-6 or 5-7 (Kentucky did beat Auburn at Auburn...I'm just saying) is possible if things fall the wrong way. Lane, have the guys shake off Alabama and get ready to go for the last 5 games, please. Thanks.
FanPosts are most often submitted by users. The views and opinions expressed in FanPosts do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions held by the editorial staff of Rocky Top Talk or SB Nation.
20 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Good post and thanks for the compliments. You guys did play a great game, and I’ll say this for Kiffin… you have to respect him for sticking with Crompton and holding the team together through adversity. This team could have easily fallen apart, but they are improving.
If he could just learn to shut his mouth he might end up being a good coach. Blaming his mismanagement of the clock at the end of the game on fears that the refs would make up a call to screw them over as part of a conspiracy to help Bama and Florida is just lame.
What you're seeing is team spirit. It's like the Holy Spirit, but more powerful.
-Hank Hill
If he could just learn to shut his mouth he might end up being a good coach.
So you think if he were any better of a coach Alabama would have definitley lost on Saturday? Apparently a bad first-year coach with a rag tag team was one kick away from beating all that Saban has worked for over the past couple years. If that’s the case you all are going to be in store for another dissappointing year. Maybe you can play Ohio State in the Sugar Bowl, Lord knows what happens to Alabama against those mid-majors.
btw
you really don’t think there is a direct correlation between how much a coach talks and their coaching ability do you? Because that would be idiotic. Nobody in their right mind will tell you Bob Knight was a bad coach because he talked too much.
Just an idiotic bammer who doesn't want to admit Coach K can coach
Hindsight is always 20/20, I am fine with the call that Kiffin made, just not with how it was executed. That kick goes in and no one disagrees…. The chances of an interception or a penalty were pretty high and the Coach was just saying what he was really thinking. I couldn’t care less if bammers or Mike Slive don’t like how it came out.
From what I hear, Kiffin hadn’t been told about the pulled hamstring till after the game too
Living in Alabama is like living 50 years in the past, they are still just as racist, just as educated, the state constitution forbids any kind of public transportation, and all they can talk about is Bear Bryant
If he didn't know about the hammy,
then there was a failure in communication somewhere. That’s kind of a big deal when you’re staking the entire game on the kicker’s leg at over 40 yards and shaky protection.
by David Hooper on Oct 27, 2009 11:04 AM EDT up reply actions
yah
it’s not a good thing when the head coach is unaware of the kickers injury
by golfballs03 on Oct 27, 2009 11:26 AM EDT up reply actions
I'm glad you chose to beat that dead horse some more
This is as fine of a post-mortem as I have read anywhere. Hit all the points with objectivity and a real fan’s pride. Thanks.
You know
I gave plenty of credit to Kiffin in my post. There’s more to being a good coach than just winning games. How about you learn the rules, act with some class, and take responsibility for what happens on the field. That’s what I was getting at there.
Also if you want to get into it, I don’t really have much of a problem with the decision to kick the ball instead of running more plays. What was stupid was letting the clock run down so far. Since it wasn’t fourth down, you should have left time for another kick if something happened like a bobbled snap, a blocked kick that your team recovers, etc.
What you're seeing is team spirit. It's like the Holy Spirit, but more powerful.
-Hank Hill
Stolen from the fanshots
But, states the case a lot more eloquently than we have time for.
I told you we would beat Georgia!! Now, as for those 9 wins in '09......
I got bored and made a blog!! SCS
Maybe if I were a Georgia or Auburn fan I would be afraid of what you guys have going on. But I’m not. I’m pretty confident that we’ll put up #4 on you guys next year, and we’ll keep rolling. All your optimism might be a little premature, but whatever. Bring it.
And there’s not comparison between Saban coming to Alabama and what Kiffin does. Saban was put in an impossible situation. If you have to choose between being truthful to the media and possibly hurting your team and family, I have no problem at all with lying to the media. Maybe you guys in Tennessee are just more honest eh? I suppose you tell your wife she does look fat in those pants.
What you're seeing is team spirit. It's like the Holy Spirit, but more powerful.
-Hank Hill
What in the world
Makes you “confident” that you guys will win in Knoxville after you barely escaped in Tuscaloosa this year? You thinkin’ Fulmer’s gonna come back or something?
I told you we would beat Georgia!! Now, as for those 9 wins in '09......
I got bored and made a blog!! SCS
by looking at the talent that we have coming back compared to what you have coming back. You lose your QB (who had a hell of a game), most of your O line, and Eric Berry. Yea, we had a close call with you this year. Our QB is in a slump (that I think he will come out of eventually). Our team was pretty tired and beat up while you guys had a week off to recuperate and prepare coming off your best performance of the year by far. Lets face it, the stars were alighted for you guys to upset us. I was very nervous about this game.
What you're seeing is team spirit. It's like the Holy Spirit, but more powerful.
-Hank Hill
Yeah
See that link below from golfballs03 and my comments therein. I’ve answered all of those “omg, we’re losing everybody!!!!11” fears and I’m “pretty confident” we’ll be juuuust fine.
I told you we would beat Georgia!! Now, as for those 9 wins in '09......
I got bored and made a blog!! SCS
You guys might be a good team next year, but I don’t think the talent gap between bama and UT will be any smaller than it is this year. It might very well be bigger. And I don’t think you’ll have all the circumstances that favored you this year either.
Barring terrible injury luck and total meltdowns..
Alabama will be the best team in the SEC and the most difficult game on our [UT] schedule next year, by far.I'm not saying "OMG you lose everyone" but you have more significant losses that Alabama.
What you're seeing is team spirit. It's like the Holy Spirit, but more powerful.
-Hank Hill
Well if that's the best they can do under such circumstances
I’m afraid you’re not going to be happy with how the rest of this season unfolds.
by golfballs03 on Oct 27, 2009 12:43 PM EDT up reply actions
Also
Fulmer owned Bama until his last two seasons – let’s not let that one get away from our collective memories.
But I think Alabama will be the best team in the SEC and the most difficult game on our schedule next year, by far.
by Will Shelton on Oct 27, 2009 12:42 PM EDT up reply actions
Meanwhile
more reasonable observers see what whats coming
See here
by golfballs03 on Oct 27, 2009 12:40 PM EDT up reply actions
the definition of a "good coach"
brought to you by Zoltar, Alabama fan.
Thank you
by golfballs03 on Oct 27, 2009 11:28 AM EDT up reply actions
fulmerized
For fear of being flamed by three of the Vol faithful
I think that was a great write up, VolnVa. Yes, most of Bama/UT fans hate the other team, but when it comes to it its football and its not the most important thing in the world.
Treating people with respect is. Yes, I [trash] talk on RBR because I have so many friends who are Vols and Tigers, and it irritates them. However, it does feel good to know you had a good time (minus the result) and so many of "our people" were pleasant to you. I don’t think I would have the heart to [trash] talk to an opponent after the game, especially one so close. Because as a Bama fan, I have been there and it sucks.
You guys played hard. That’s all I’ll say for fear of the locals coming through and blasting me for not laying manna at the feet of your coach ha ha.
It is important to find someone who allows you to fulfill your dreams. It is luck if that person finds you, too – Isaiah Zagar
by BamaReturns07 on Oct 27, 2009 6:42 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Rocky Top Talk
by Joel Hollingsworth on Oct 27, 2009 8:08 PM EDT reply actions

by 
























