Tennessee Volunteers unable to beat both Mississippi State and poor officiating
I'm sure Will will have a much more reasoned post game for this one, but I want to focus on the last minute of the game. Play-by-play style.
- Mississippi State up 61-57 with a minute to play. Vols run a play for Wayne Chism to shoot a three, and he hits it. MSU 61-60. The referees were not involved in this play.
- MSU runs some time off the clock and then drives to the basket. The dribbler is seriously not even touched, but he falls down cutting, so a foul is called on Wayne Chism. This is the worst call I have ever seen. Commentators: "Bruce is beside himself." Upon seeing the replay: "Oh my goodness, no contact whatsoever. Wow, that's an anticipation call." MSU hits the first and misses the second. MSU 62, Vols 60.
- Vols call time out to set up a play with 12 seconds left. J.P. Prince passes the ball in to Bobby Maze, who passes it back to Prince. Prince takes off for the basket but runs into an MSU guy. One ref calls a foul on MSU and another calls a travel on Prince. I don't know. It looked like he traveled, but the foul may have caused it. The refs decide on the
travelfoul, which was probably therightwrong call. MSU ball, MSU up 62-60. - Prince at the line. Hits the first. MSU up 62-61. Prince misses the second, but two MSU players knock the ball out of bounds. Vol ball, down by one.
- Tyler Smith to in-bound the pass. The refs arms are counting down the five seconds he has to get it done. At four and 3/4, he calls time out. The ref calls a five-second violation. This, too, is a bad call. Not quite egregiously bad like the first against Tennessee, but clearly wrong. Commentators: "Bruce Pearl is beside himself." Yes, again. On the replay: "Oh, boy. I thought he asked for it just before. Most officials would give it to him, too." MSU shooting free throws, up 62-61.
- MSU to in-bound the ball with 9.6 seconds left. Prince kicks it out of bounds. Now MSU must in-bound it stationary. They get it to a guy in the corner, and two Vols immediately trap him. He steps out of bounds. Vol ball under their own basket, down by one.
- Tyler Smith in-bounds the ball to Prince, who immediately passes it back to Smith, but it's intercepted. MSU player fouled. MSU up by one and shooting two.
- MSU hits both free throws to go up by three. Pearl designs a nice play to get Scotty Hopson a three, but he misses. Game over.
This is just the end of the game, too. About ten minutes into the second half, the game thread is rife with complaints about poor officiating and allegations of a conspiracy to get more SEC teams intot the NCAA Tournament. I don't know about that.
What I do know, though, as that there was one egregiously wrong call that went against Tennessee and another that was clearly wrong, all in the last sixty seconds. Look, these guys make mistakes, too, but to be honest -- and I never say this -- this looked worse than just wrong. Maybe it doesn't get to "intentional," but it most certainly was really, really bad.
Oh, well. On to Selection Sunday and the announcements of where and against whom we'll be seeking revenge.
12 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
You're wrong about the Prince travel/foul call
The refs went with the foul, which is why Prince ended up at the line as you wrote in the next bullet point.
Lou Brock loves Lamp.
You're right
Fixed. Thanks.
Rocky Top Talk
by Joel Hollingsworth on Mar 15, 2009 4:04 PM EDT up reply actions
I guess I didn't find the officiating as terrible as the clock operation there at the end...
… I disagreed with the foul called on Chism, but I didn’t feel like the rest of it was that bad. The 5-second call could have gone either way, and I was screaming for Tyler to call a timeout a full second before he tried to do so. I really didn’t feel like we were robbed of that game by anything other than our inability to hit point-blank shots all day, bad free throw shooting, and poor decision-making by J.P. Prince.
Lou Brock loves Lamp.
Yeah
We didn’t play that well, either. I really don’t think the five second call could have gone either way. There is a cadence to the refs arms, and Smith got it just before the last down beat.
But you’re right. We couldn’t hit in-close shots for much of the game, and we should have been able to put it away, but couldn’t. And that last pass by Pajamas blew an opportunity we had been given.
That and the bad calls did go both ways.
Rocky Top Talk
by Joel Hollingsworth on Mar 15, 2009 4:06 PM EDT up reply actions
I think officiating has generally been bad all season long...
… I don’t remember it ever being as bad as it has seemed this year, but I can generally live with it as long as it is not favoring one team over the other. I thought the bad calls went both ways today.
Lou Brock loves Lamp.
I never believe
That the refs decide the game unless it’s on a call that can’t be overcome. IE if that 5 second call had happened with .5 seconds left.
But the officiating in that game was still piss poor. In watching that game do you think that MSU warranted 13 more FT opportunities than the Vols? The Vols got called for 6 more fouls than MSU, despite the fact that Tennessee aggressively went to the basket much of the game. What was called a foul by Tennessee was not done so against Mississippi State.
The refs definately affected the outcome of the game in a generous way. They also worked to control the pace of the game, which is not the ref’s job to do.
Hats off to Miss State, I don’t think they played dirty or anything. I’m glad they are in the Tournament but I wish the game was called better.
by bobo_the_vol on Mar 15, 2009 4:09 PM EDT up reply actions
Clearly
we think a lot like.
I still think if this was a Mississippi State blog, we’d be crying shenanigans on JP Prince’s “walk”, and the fact that no foul was called when the kid went out of bounds after that.
I think there was a foul on the inbounds
But the JP call was a foul, he got an arm shoved in him and definitely a sizable bump while he was moving.
by bobo_the_vol on Mar 15, 2009 4:11 PM EDT up reply actions
Yeah, I agree with you
Except that I think the two calls against Tennessee were more clearly wrong than the ones against MSU. No big deal now, though. It’s over. On to the next one.
Rocky Top Talk
by Joel Hollingsworth on Mar 15, 2009 4:23 PM EDT up reply actions
I'd agree with that
about ours being more clearly wrong
by Will Shelton on Mar 15, 2009 4:25 PM EDT up reply actions
Horrorshow all around.
Yeesh, officiators, think of all the Southerners just off their post-holiday bypass surgeries.
________________________________
I will give my shirt for Tennessee today.

by 



























