Rocky Top Talk: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Jeff Sullivan's MLB Trade Deadline Primer

The Pendulum Swings in Knoxville

My favorite class during my illustrious tenure at the University of Tennessee was History of Revolution.  And what you discover is that no matter how violent or drastic the revolution, there is always a reactionary period that follows, and usually more than one.  The pendulum swings back and forth, from one end of the spectrum to the other.  It happens in politics and elections, and it happens in sports.

Since we've got all the fire, tear gas and rabblerabblerabble of a revolution in Knoxville, it's worth noting that the Vols' next move appears most likely to be in line with the pendulum swing - I think the next head coach is more likely to resemble Phillip Fulmer than Lane Kiffin.

14 months ago, we wanted change - and despite what's happened in the last two days, I would still say that we needed change - and we hired a guy who was different from the last one in every way.  Kiffin was younger, louder, infinitely less experienced and infinitely less familiar with Tennessee Football.  And he was never more distant from Phillip than in the way he left.

So when Mike Hamilton - who is feeling a more tangible heat this time around - is looking for the next guy, the idea holds that he'll be thinking of safety and stability more than the need to go younger and make a splash.  Some things will always be essential - the guy has to recruit nationally, and of course, he has to inspire confidence that he can win and ultimately have the results that we hope follow - but now Hamilton is much less likely to take a chance on someone the same way he did with Kiffin.  And he is much more likely to select someone who will buy in to the Tennessee Family.

This means Tennessee's next coach is more likely to come from the David Cutcliffe pool than the Mike Leach pool.

Star-divide

Brent Hubbs wrote a piece on VolQuest this afternoon that touched on this idea ($):

If anything was learned from the month-long search 15 months ago, it's that you have to have a coach who is not just selling it, but who gets it. That doesn't mean he has to be a Tennessee person or someone who has been a Vol before.

It just has to be a person who understands that when you take a job at a place like Tennessee, you are not just signing up for big checks and long hours. You are committing to a lifestyle.

We thought Lane Kiffin was John Calipari, but perhaps he was Billy Gillispie.

The answer is not to rehire Phillip Fulmer - that's an unrealistic idea, and a bad one too.  But Hamilton knows that the next chance he takes could be his last one. 

David Cutcliffe is safe.  David Cutcliffe is a guy who would make the majority of Tennessee fans nod their heads in agreement - moreso than when Kiffin was hired.  David Cutcliffe can recruit because his middle name is Manning.  We already know Cutcliffe can handle the x's and o's.  And we already know David Cutcliffe is a Tennessee guy.

It doesn't necessarily have to be him.  He's just the closest thing to Fulmer's end of the spectrum.

Where does Will Muschamp fall on this continuum?  How much of a risk is Troy Calhoun?  These are all factors Hamilton must weigh.  The coaching staff that was so crucial to Kiffin's hire will probably still look good with Cutcliffe (emphasis offense with on Kippy Brown, Trooper Taylor?) or Muschamp (emphasis on defense with Lance Thompson). 

But the odds Hamilton goes far from the norm are much lower this time, especially as far from the norm as Lane Kiffin was last year.  Thanks to Kiffin, the pendulum has swung back towards tradition, stability, and integrity.  The next move is Mike Hamilton's, who has to find a way to play it both safe enough and right enough to keep his job.

Hamilton's best interests remain Tennessee's best interests for now.  Lane Kiffin wasn't the right move for the Vols in the long run.  For all of our sakes, hopefully the pendulum stops at the right guy on its way back home.

0 recs  |  Comment 27 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

The more I think about it

…the more I like the idea of hiring Cutcliffe. However (and please correct me if I’m wrong), didn’t he publicly reject the idea of coming back to Tennessee last year? Granted, this was just after his first season, and we know he has far more class than Kiffin. I still think I would prefer Muschamp for a variety of reasons (younger, more of a national name), but I think either would get the ship righted sooner rather than later.

So Sayth King Zach I

by kingofzachland on Jan 13, 2010 7:21 PM EST reply actions  

I think his rejection last year was directly linked to Fulmer

and I don’t think he was ever really approached last year for the same reason. But he had no problem following Randy Sanders; I know Fulmer and Cut were/are much closer than Cut and Sanders, but I think a year may make a difference. If approached I can’t imagine him saying no, and I can’t imagine Phillip not being on board with it a year removed.

by Will on Jan 13, 2010 7:26 PM EST up reply actions  

It'll have to be a heck of a sell job the the fans/players.

Calhoun is a great coach, but most people associate him only with military academy football and don’t think about his pro-style and NFL time. Hamilton seemed to like him the first time around, so he’s definitely a name that can’t be dismissed, but I’m not sure that Hamilton can convince everybody to give him a fair shake. That’s my big concern.

by Hooper on Jan 13, 2010 7:38 PM EST up reply actions  

Makes sense

I think Tenn wants a bigger name, and like you said most do not know about his NFL coaching experience.

by Jeremy Mauss on Jan 13, 2010 8:19 PM EST up reply actions  

Sticking to my guns

I do not see Fulmer as the HC again. I’m not that deluded :)

As AD? Quite possible. I won’t lie, my rose colored glasses think thats a helluva deal, but then I like and respect the man.

Coach? I really lean towards Mike Leach. I think he’s a stayer, I think he’s aggressive enough to do a really good job, he has a good reputation despite the current status qup he is in. I think Mike would win fans on both sides of the aisles, the aggressive and the traditionalist and even the “I don’t care who we have I just want to win every damn ball game” group

"Gentlemen, it is better to have died as a small boy than to fumble this football." John Heisman

by BloodSpite on Jan 13, 2010 7:38 PM EST reply actions  

I've heard nothing but bad things about Mike Leach

he doesn’t recruit, he doesn’t give a flip about defense…all he wants to do is score tons of points and talk about pirates

"Albert hits good pitches hard and bad pitches even harder. And when he gets in the batter's box, if you pray, then you start praying. And if you don't pray, you think about starting."--Brian Bannister

by VolsnCards5 on Jan 13, 2010 7:50 PM EST up reply actions  

Yeah

Something like 40% of all lawyers have significant health problems. Too many cope with alcohol or drugs. Some with blogging. Some with pirates.

Rocky Top Talk

by Joel on Jan 13, 2010 9:54 PM EST up reply actions  

Outsider looking in...

…I think UT is much bigger then Lane Kiffin, and will be MUCH better off without him…

I’d say “don’t let the door hit ya’”… !

Good luck guys finding a Top Notch coach… Unfortunately for the rest of us, I know you will….

Steelers fan 1st! UK is my 2nd love.

by vinceuk1 on Jan 13, 2010 7:56 PM EST reply actions  

DOOR!

(made ya look)

Simulated Gameday Experience - just like the real thing, only we have smoke machines.

by Graysnail on Jan 13, 2010 8:20 PM EST up reply actions  

LOL

How did we ever get away from that, anyhow? Such a perfect one-word gem. This has to be revived for the basketball games.

by Hooper on Jan 13, 2010 8:40 PM EST up reply actions  

It's really context-appropriate.

I’ve only revived it given the events of the last 24 hours (it seemed thematically appropriate). It’s easy to drive it into the ground, I think.

That being said, our first game against Kentucky will blow the doors off the place.

Simulated Gameday Experience - just like the real thing, only we have smoke machines.

by Graysnail on Jan 13, 2010 8:57 PM EST up reply actions  

Might be

where you are.
 Arkansas and Texas seem to hate each other out here. So I’m constantly hearing about Texas, Texas tech, etc.

When Nutt first left Arkansas folks were scrambling hoping to get Leach up here.

The guy has his Doctorate degree and a Masters in Sports.

He is offensive heavy, but he’s good at it. He’s set several offensive records with Texas Tech, Valdosta and Kentucky. He’s currently 85 and 43.

He doesn’t have to be a defensive genius. Thats why you have defensive coordinators.

"Gentlemen, it is better to have died as a small boy than to fumble this football." John Heisman

by BloodSpite on Jan 13, 2010 7:59 PM EST reply actions  

Go for a home run on this one guys.......find some one you know can get you back to being a

top 10 school in 2-3 years………speaking from our experience, the rest of the world can go to Hades, when you have the right guy, life is so much better. Dont settle for an also-ran. Gillispie could have set us back another 5 years, had we not have gotten Calipari. And no matter what anyone thinks of the guy………he has been all he was advertised to be and more.

Remember, we're having fun now!!!

by ALLBLUCAT on Jan 13, 2010 8:00 PM EST reply actions  

I hope you guys get a good coach.

I am not sure who is out there for you … just don’t do what Bama did and hire a Shula.

Good Luck.

by Big_Al_Fan on Jan 13, 2010 10:10 PM EST reply actions  

Or a Fran.

Or a …

;-)

(seriously, though. thanks.)

by Hooper on Jan 13, 2010 10:18 PM EST up reply actions  

I can't decide who I'd rather have....

Cutcliffe or Muschamp.

But I know I’d be happy with either. Muschamp is a little more exciting, obviously, but I always thought Cutcliffe was one of the best things we had going for us in the 90s…and we had a lot of great things going for us in the 90s.

by davy on Jan 13, 2010 10:26 PM EST reply actions  

I'm not sold on Cutcliffe

Great Coordinator, do good things with the Vols in the past. I don’t know, I just feel like he’s not the answer.

by bsmithinc on Jan 14, 2010 5:28 AM EST up reply actions  

I'd prefer Edsall or Calhoun over Cut

But my top choices are still Muschamp and Patterson (both are looking iffy at this point though).

by Incipient_Senescence on Jan 14, 2010 9:29 AM EST up reply actions  

me too

but i hope we are looking outside of them too. i think we should in touch with kirby smart, kyle wittingham… I just think what we offer would interest a lot of coaches. I want to hear more names out there…

by golfballs03 on Jan 14, 2010 9:43 AM EST up reply actions  

Give it to Kippy ...

My 2 cents , give this fiasco over to Kippy . I was one who drank the Kool-Aid , that we needed to go outside the UT family for this last hire , etc etc ….If Kippy kept control over the team while our previous coach who will not be named was slithering out the door -he has my vote . He is a Tennessee guy with a great coaching resume and he UNDERSTANDS our culture and the new culture of the kids we are recruiting . I am also fed up with this whole " having to recruit nationally " BS . There are more than enough kids in the Southeast region who can play here and more importantly want to be at UT for the sake of being at UT -not as a springboard to the pros ..I have had it with all the prima donna 4/5 star guys who are simply looking past us to get them where they want to go . Alabama has made a living out of guys who just want to play for Alabama -that is where we need to get back to …

by voljay on Jan 14, 2010 8:37 AM EST reply actions  

Mark Ingram grew up in Michigan.

Crazy talk. There are absolutely NOT enough players in the southeast region who want to play for Tennessee that would keep us competitive.

Official MCM Hater!

Retire #9!

by gramsey712 on Jan 14, 2010 9:35 AM EST up reply actions  

I was not talking about Ingram

You do not think there are enough guys in the SE region ???Can I have some of your stash

by voljay on Jan 14, 2010 2:08 PM EST up reply actions  

Then obviously I missed your point.

Because we have to recruit nationally. And this is so obvious that I am not sure why I started an argument about it.

Alabama recruits nationally. That was my point about Ingram. He did not call Alabama and offer himself a scholarship.

Official MCM Hater!

Retire #9!

by gramsey712 on Jan 14, 2010 2:31 PM EST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Tennessee Volunteers.
Start posting about the Volunteers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Powert_small
Why do we care so much?

Recent FanPosts

Huey_ut_small
alternate versions of Rocky Top
028_small
NCAA Football 11 Online Dynasty for Xbox 360
Small
Bryce Brown Not Returning to UT
Jason_as_rasterboy_for_twitter_small
Vandy Just Became Much More Intimidating
Fiddler_on_the_roof_fiddler_1__small
So yeah, about today
Armantipanther_small
Troy is burning: Pete Carroll is the new Helen and Kiffin is left holding the bill.
Jason_as_rasterboy_for_twitter_small
Endorsement of Coach Dooley from Joseph Addai
Image73_small
Best spots to tailgate?
Image73_small
How do you feel about Kenny Chesney? (rant)

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Animated Drive Charts

RTT Classics

RTT Classics 2008 Animated BlogPoll2007 Animated BlogPollLOL! Your logo is so scary! Welcome to Rocky Top Talk Tradition! Fiddlin' on the Roof2008 Animated BlogPoll The Season of Which We Do Not Speak Pearlfection Case Study: 2QB Systems and the 2005 Tennessee Volunteers The 2007 College Football Blogger Awards The 2006 College Football Blogger Awards The 20 coolest college football logos The 10 worst college football logos The 29 most boring college football logos 2006 Animated BCS Race 2005 Animated Race to the Rose Bowl

YouTube

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Photo +14 updates

QB Jeremiah Masoli Headed To Ole Miss After Being Dismissed From Oregon

Photo

With Apologies To Randy Edsall, The Big East Remains Mostly Harmless

FILE -- This is an Oct. 18, 2008 file photo showing Connecticut corner back Jasper Howard (6) trying to get the crowd into the game during the fourth quarter of an NCAA college football game against Rutgers, in Piscataway, N.J.   Jasper Howard had his little sisters' names tatooed on his chest. His friends say it was a constant reminder of why he was at U Conn _ to provide his family with a better life than the one he had in Miami's Little Haiti. (AP Photo/Mel Evans, File) link

In Defense Of Big East Football

More from SBNation.com >


Editor-in-Chief

Fiddler_on_the_roof_fiddler_1__small Joel

Senior Editor

Gromit_small Hooper

Tennessee_logo_small Will