Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Explaining Jeremy Lin's Early, Surprising Success

Lane Kiffin, Tennessee, and Volunteers Fans: An Epilogue

Now that Derek Dooley has officially begun the next story in Tennessee football history, the time has come to close the book on Lane Kiffin's time in Knoxville. It's been a wild 14 months to say the least, and I think that we're all ready to just let the past be the past and look forward to the future.  And so, this will serve as my final words on Lane Kiffin as a Tennessee head coach.  If he comes up in context of discussion, so be it, but I have no plans of focusing on him and UT any more.  Closure is good, but obsession is unhealthy.

Now, while I don't normally like to write directly about myself, I should provide a little context in this case.  I'm not a person who holds a grudge and I don't tend to lead with emotions.  I like to look at the positive sides of things and I have a tendency to play devil's advocate - especially in heated conversations.  Because of this, I really don't have any desire to bash Kiffin or to launch into another rant about him.  To be perfectly honest, I'm really not even mad at the guy anymore.  I'll explain that in a bit.

RECAP

First, a little reminder of the context in which Kiffin was hired.  Heading into the 2007-2008 offseason, the Volunteers had a big problem.  The team was getting passed up by the reinvented teams in the league (especially the two big rivals, Florida and Alabama).  Rivalry wins were getting scarce, and because the program was plodding along in the same direction it had been going for nearly 20 years, there was little sense of Tennessee adapting to the new landscape.  That's why David Clawson was brought in - to reinvent the offense and bring something new to the table.  We didn't know how it would work, but being the optimistic bunch, we certainly hoped.

Star-divide

When the 2008 season hit, we found out that our dice roll had come up snake-eyes when, during the UCLA game, the team couldn't manage more than 14 points in the first half, despite four interceptions by the defense.  Then we found out just how difficult it was to re-roll ones throughout the rest of the seasons.  Snake-eyes became snake-bit.  The change didn't work; UT was still losing ground; and the second problem hit - the one that ultimately brought in Lane Kiffin.

We were tired of seeing Fulmerball.  Those who might like to run Mike Hamilton out of town for firing Fulmer must remember that the firing was not optional.  The athletic department was losing money in a big way.  Ticket sales were down.  Marketing revenue (e.g. t-shirt sales) were down.  Booster donations were down.  And everybody was flat-out angry.  The program cannot survive without income, and the income was not coming in.  This is why we got Kiffin.

What Kiffin did well for UT.

Emotions have a way of polarizing our view of the world - of filtering out the glare that obscures our opinion.  The fact is that Lane Kiffin did a lot of positive things for the program in his time here.  Recruiting was going very well - very well.  Not only was top-end talent coming, but it was coming in a cohesive way that would have formed a great team.  The players were having fun again.  Special teams still needed work, but the offense and defense were humming along quite nicely, all things considered.

Player grades were up.  Off-field incidents were down.  The majority of credit belongs to the players, who did most of the turning-around by their own pride in themselves.  (Aside:  note that none of the players who were here before Kiffin were arrested.)  But Kiffin does deserve some credit.  He did tighten down classroom requirements and he did actively check up on the players.

And Kiffin worked tremendously hard for the team.  We can't ignore his positive contributions; it's not fair to him and it's dishonest by us.  If we're going to promote Tennessee values, we have to start by living up to them, and that means giving credit where it's due.

Where Kiffin failed UT.

Today, we point to a lack of respect for the NCAA and for Tennessee tradition as reasons to not want Kiffin around anymore.  A week ago today, we pointed to his aggressiveness and willingness to challenge the rules as simply doing everything he could to win.  And we saw his willingness to change things as not allowing tradition to keep UT from developing into its full potential.  There are pros and cons to both sides of those issues.  We chose to ignore the bad before, and it's easy to ignore the good now.  But these are not failures, per se.  Kiffin was simply doing what he thought would bring the most wins, and we were cheering him on for it.  He was right:  win and nobody will care how you got there.  It's true for every fan base, whether we like it or not.

His ultimate failure was that Lane Kiffin did not give himself a chance to be a part of the Tennessee family.  Let's be honest here.  He was raised in privilege as the son of a very famous and obsessively hard-working coach.  He grew up around NFL players, TV networks, and high rollers.  He had everything he wanted in life, and he is used to getting whatever he goes after.  He's learned how to not get turned down, and he's absolutely brilliant at that.  But ultimately, all of that has taught him to view the world in terms of himself rather than viewing himself in terms of the world.  It's Kiffin's universe, and we're all witnesses to how great he can make himself.

And that's why I'm not angry with him.

I'm a little sad, really.  He's a very good coach.  He's a great recruiter and organizer.  He is an effective head coach and he has the potential to win championships.  And he has no idea how to celebrate that with the community at large.  It's why he couldn't see that, even though USC may be his dream job, that being a UT coach for only one year should have ethically prevented him from taking the job.  At 35 years old, he had plenty of time to become the USC head coach - especially if USC does end up in trouble with the NCAA in the near future.  But a few more years at UT would have allowed him to finish what he started in Knoxville and give back to the community that trusted him to change things.

Even though he did many very good things here, Tennessee's anger toward him has nothing to do with what we're now missing in him.  Our anger stems only from the way he left.

FIN

But it's over now, and I will never see the sun rise on a day where I set out to write about Lane Kiffin, Tennessee head coach.  Like all of us, Lane Kiffin is human.  The memory of his time here serves as a reminder of what that means.

I wish him well.  I wish USC well.  I never really had any interest in USC before and I don't now (not even to cheer against them)..  But I do look forward to enjoying the Tennessee community - a group of people in gaudy orange whose ability to sing in harmony at a football stadium intrigued me long before I thought it even possible I'd be in the middle of them.

Comment 35 comments  |  2 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

I'm not mad at him for leaving

But I’m still pretty pissed for that Jim Rome interview. I think that’s worthy of drawing ire, and I’ll certainly be rooting against USC and advising my cousin not to go there if Kiffin is still the coach.

That said, we don’t want him to be our focus at Tennessee. Let’s go Coach Dooley!

by Incipient_Senescence on Jan 16, 2010 6:18 PM EST reply actions  

Believe so

If you want to claim that you liked it where you used to be (and that they’re only angry because you did such a good job), you don’t take cheap shots at them on national TV.

by Incipient_Senescence on Jan 16, 2010 6:30 PM EST up reply actions  

Good article

I feel close to the same way. “He” did instill discipline, both in the classroom as well as the field of play. He could have really built something here.

Spot on about the USC job. He could have allowed USC to hire someone else to navigate them through the inevitable probation, and then become head coach in 3-5 years.

It comes down to ethics, like you said. Society as a whole has trended towards a belief that if something makes you happy, you should do it, regardless of how it affects those around you. Whether the subject is relationships, money management or coaching, this belief permeates the thought processes of many people.

Thank you very little.

by pound the rock on Jan 16, 2010 6:34 PM EST reply actions  

The inevitable probation

Call me cynical – many have before – but I really think he sees the inevitable probation as a built-in excuse for not winning (he’s had one everywhere he’s been a HC,) and it will give him a longer period of time as their head coach if he doesn’t win quickly enough for people there.

Lou Brock loves Lamp.

by birdjam on Jan 17, 2010 5:37 PM EST up reply actions  

Still hope USC gets the death penalty

but that has more to do with my dislike of that university’s sports teams then my dislike for the current head football coach

"Albert hits good pitches hard and bad pitches even harder. And when he gets in the batter's box, if you pray, then you start praying. And if you don't pray, you think about starting."--Brian Bannister

by VolsnCards5 on Jan 16, 2010 7:06 PM EST reply actions  

Well written.

I did not appreciate the way he left, but I think it’s like a breakup…the anger lifts with time. And the anger of leaving is because of the good things that he did do and the way he left…not to mention the comments (Jim Rome). If he was a complete failure here, well, then let’s gift wrap him to USC. But I, too, am done with Kiffin as of our press conference last night at 9pm. Go VOLS!

Welcome Coach Dooley!!!

by RockyTopinKY on Jan 16, 2010 8:37 PM EST reply actions  

Nice article

rec’d

...just apologize for not thanking me.

by kidbourbon on Jan 16, 2010 9:03 PM EST reply actions  

Great Article

And hopefully someday I’ll be as understanding and forgiving as you…….But I’m not there yet. I still hope they lose every game and his wife gets fat.

by Volcrazy on Jan 16, 2010 9:09 PM EST reply actions  

Heh.

We’re all different, and I’m certainly not telling anybody else how to react. That’s just where I am.

by David Hooper on Jan 16, 2010 9:22 PM EST up reply actions  

Fat?

Maybe the fourth kid will do it?

Lou Brock loves Lamp.

by birdjam on Jan 17, 2010 5:38 PM EST up reply actions  

well said hooper, wish i were as cool as you

ps. cutcliffe metaphor that would have made us feel better?

The Dual Threat, Official Enforcer/Stat Geek of MCM.

by hal41605 on Jan 17, 2010 12:12 AM EST reply actions  

Oh, right. Cutcliffe = Tennessee's Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict XVI)

Conservative. Familiar, if not perfectly local (Ratzinger was Bavarian and the closest thing to a ‘Roman’ candidate). Steeped in the traditions. Very intelligent. And also an older guy who wouldn’t be expected to try to hang on for a whole lot of years (especially, for Cutcliffe, with his heart history).

The traditionalists would have been happy with the connection to earlier years, and those who didn’t like the pick would at least take comfort in that he’d be gone before too long.

by David Hooper on Jan 17, 2010 12:25 AM EST up reply actions  

that's really good.

so does that make ole miss the hitler youth?

The Dual Threat, Official Enforcer/Stat Geek of MCM.

by hal41605 on Jan 17, 2010 12:33 AM EST up reply actions  

I was rather proud of it.

Ah, well. Tonight, I’m happier of how things worked out. Hope that’ll last for years to come.

by David Hooper on Jan 17, 2010 12:40 AM EST up reply actions  

As far as being cool.

I’ve just learned to be happy and content with my raging nerdiness.

by David Hooper on Jan 17, 2010 12:26 AM EST up reply actions  

Oh, the other kind of cool.

Perhaps I should quit conversing with myself now.

by David Hooper on Jan 17, 2010 12:26 AM EST up reply actions  

boths kinds can apply

The Dual Threat, Official Enforcer/Stat Geek of MCM.

by hal41605 on Jan 17, 2010 12:33 AM EST up reply actions  

Great post

Sorry to troll. I had become a Vols fan under Kiff and will continue. Perhaps one thing missing from the discussion of Kiff’s motivation was the pressure from his wife and three young daughters to move back to the place that his kids call home. Hopefully, some of you with kids can relate to that. No one saw this coming or expected it. Not now. The opening at SC was as surprising as the Haitian earthquake.

Anyway, Dooley looks like a great hire, the recruiting class will be saved and then some, and Bryce Brown may win the Heisman in 2012. Still hope the Vols give the Tide and Gators hell.

by DFWTrojan on Jan 17, 2010 12:52 AM EST reply actions  

If that's trolling, the internet's become really soft. ;-)

No worries.

I’ve heard some rumors on that topic, but haven’t seen anything of substance. Not that they need to broadcast it or anything, but it would have been a nice gesture to have been a little more up-front with the Tennessee fans about that. We understand family.

But again, what’s done is done and we’ll have to agree to an uneasy truce on a few topics based on opposing sides of an unfortunate coin. Best of luck.

by David Hooper on Jan 17, 2010 1:16 AM EST up reply actions  

Uh-oh, here comes Ogre...

NERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRDS!

Thank you very little.

by pound the rock on Jan 17, 2010 1:42 AM EST up reply actions  

You're not trolling

the other 99% of Southern Cal fans calling us ‘hillbillies’ on your board are, but not you.

by danmarcel on Jan 17, 2010 6:09 PM EST up reply actions  

Actually I take it back

“Unless they are red overalls!”

So, get bent and go home.

by danmarcel on Jan 17, 2010 6:15 PM EST up reply actions  

Nothing wrong with a little soft trolling

Cliffs Notes version is that it’s not that he left, it’s how he left. It seems to really be his dream job, but you must forgive us if we feel a little dirty and don’t believe a single word that slips his lips.

Not speaking for other Vol fans, but the calling of kids already on campus, who were preparing to go to class the next day is what sticks in my craw. Then there was the none-too-subtle shots at UT after he left, which were just unnecessary considering UT took a chance on him after he had been cast onto the coaching scrap heap.

It can be defended by the “winning at all costs” argument, as can any ethically reprehensible coaching behavior.

I’m over it and ready to see what our new Double D coach can do. Just hope Bryce Brown decides to continue to rep the Orange and we can piece together a decent O-Line.

Thank you very little.

by pound the rock on Jan 17, 2010 1:41 AM EST reply actions  

Have to disagree a little bit...

Especially with the statement that Coach Sprinkles worked hard for UT. I feel like he worked hard for himself promoting himself. It’s clear from his post-departure statements that he did not care a flip for Tennessee as in institution and that it was merely a stepping stone….albeit a quick 1 hop stepping stone. Listen to his comments. All the BS about having to get the Tennessee brand out there as being the reason for all his toe stomping….No, he just needed something that sounded good so people wouldn’t fixate on the idea that he just screwed up. All the excuses he made for his missteps, we for the most part believed because, heck, we didn’t want to admit to ourselves that maybe Tennessee was doing things the wrong way. And now all we’re left with is a vulnerable inferiority complex, an ongoing investigation, and utter bitterness. This guy can come up with a slick response for just about anything. And anyone will believe it. Heck we believed he actually wanted to be here. All he did was eschew the very things that makes us Tennessee and run up a huge bar tab with every other coach in the SEC. Look at his presser at SC…instead of going to war with every other coach in his new conference, a la December-January of 08/09, he started talking about the healthy respect he had for all the great coaches in the Pac-10. I’m sorry but the coaches in the Pac-10 don’t hold a candle to the achievements of current coaches in the SEC. He never gave a you-know-what about being here and he never wanted to stay. I’m sorry, this guy had no internalization of the position of Head Football Coach of the University of Freaking Tennessee. He worked for himself and no other. He used us. Plain and simple. I’ve said it before, Sprinkles is the must successful self promoter I’ve ever seen.

As for the statement, “he is a good football coach.” More disagreement! A football coach is more than just playcalling, X’s and O’s, and recruiting. A 7-6 record with more quality moral victories than quality victories, plus his past at Oakland—-sorry, I just can’t get see the indicators there telling us that this guy was a quality football coach. “Coach in what way did you leave Tennessee in better way than when you found it? Well, we won 2 more games, we lost prettier to Florida and Bama, and we left them with a great incoming roster (which we are about to raid).” To quote Uncle Verne Lundquist: “Are you KIDDING me?”

NO, I see a brash, immature thirty something that racks up violations like no other, stepped, no stomped, on the toes of coaching greats in this league, and is now taking every opportunity to take a dig at the very institution that gave him a shot when no other school dared. Yellow shirts, “I had to get the word out on Tennessee,” et cetera et cetera et cetera. Sprinkles had no respect for anything. IMHO, respect is something that every “good coach” has.

His inability to move on from his time at USC ended up with him driving this proud program in another direction—-and he did that rather halfway. So now we’re stuck in this curious purgatory of what we were, what Sprinkle’s wanted us to be, and, now where we want or think we should be. That’s why I loved what Dooley had to say about every Program being unique and that there is no cookie cutter solution for all of College Football. Dooley is saying that he is going to do it the Tennessee way. Hallefreakinglujah.

Will, I feel like you are trying to write something cathartic to gain perspective and move on. And in order to move on in a healthy way, you are trying to do it through the most positive way possible. But I just can’t bring myself to agree with you (frankly, I think you are being way too nice) on those points. It’s a nice sentiment and mature way to operate, but I can’t do it without thinking about all the harm that was done with Sprinkles’ hire and subsequent flight. But I will move on. We got to. But that doesn’t mean I can’t enjoy the Schadenfreude when Karma rears its head and Coach Sprinkles gets to experience something akin to what he forced upon the Tennessee Volunteers.

As for DFWTrojan, I’ve been to the SC blog and I noticed the uneasiness and worries about ethics when the topic of Chief Red Bull recruiting our mid term enrollees came up. I would have posted too but you all have a three day wait period before one can post. But believe you me, if you ever feel a bit of uneasiness or cringe when Sprinkle’s says something stupid or disparaging or makes some ridiculous excuse that everyone else but you seems to buy….then you will know how a lot of Volunteer fans felt over the past several months. I’ve got no problems with SC. None. But I think you have a snake in your house. A snake with a very good coach (his father) in his corner. But a snake nonetheless. Monte can’t be there to keep his Sprinkles out of trouble forever.

Someday we'll look back on this and plow into a parked car.

by MeytonPanning on Jan 17, 2010 2:59 AM EST reply actions   2 recs

Well Said

You post about the little dbag and his ogre is very well written, you must have put some thought into your post. Too bad so many of the so called journalist cant write something half as good.

by bornbama1 on Jan 27, 2010 6:49 PM EST up reply actions  

I hate lane kiffin and now I hate USC

that man is a dbag and i wish him the worst at USC. I hope we play him someday..

by cincyvol6198 on Jan 17, 2010 11:14 AM EST reply actions  

You get your wish

contracted for a home and home in 2018-19, I think. Will Lane still be coaching USC then?

by DFWTrojan on Jan 17, 2010 2:33 PM EST up reply actions  

Probably not

Once Carroll fails in the NFL, again, do you really think USC is gonna let Mr. USC himself go to another school?
I’s thinks nots.

by bsmithinc on Jan 17, 2010 2:53 PM EST up reply actions  

2021 & 2022 actually

The Dual Threat, Official Enforcer/Stat Geek of MCM.

by hal41605 on Jan 17, 2010 3:20 PM EST up reply actions  

we have really juiced the schedule for the future

home and homes against:
oklahoma in 14-15
uconn in 15-16
nebraska in 16-17
ohio state in 18-19
usc in 21-22

The Dual Threat, Official Enforcer/Stat Geek of MCM.

by hal41605 on Jan 17, 2010 3:26 PM EST up reply actions  

everyday for 14 months I woke up dreading that there would be a new kiffin-scandal that I would have to smile and embrace because it was “all part of kiffin’s genius plan.” I don’t miss that at all. I expected him to leave in a few years, either being fired or for another job that offered more money and celebrity, and my biggest concern of this was that he would leave Orgeron behind to take over as head coach and UT would become Ole Miss circa 2005. I am only pissed that he left the way he did, when he did, and how he did. But I am not sorry to see him go.

by vol95 on Jan 17, 2010 11:47 AM EST reply actions  

He is unethicable...

So, I guess it is better we found out now rather than later. I have to admit, he taught me to trust my gut and not my ears. My gut warned me that he was role-playing, but the loss of Phillip was so expensive, I didn’t listen to it and was determined to throw my shoulder into the change. What was the choice? So, now he is back home and recruiting 13 year olds and we have a legacy SEC son as coach. So, it was a lesson. An expensive one, but a lesson just the same.

by tennesseetarheel on Feb 8, 2010 10:19 AM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Tennessee Volunteers.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Checkerboard_enzone_small
My Signing Day Experience

Recent FanPosts

Vollyroger_small
Tennessee vs. Northern Illinois baseball series
20050073_detail_small
2010 LSU Game: Is Dooley Secretly A Genius?
20050073_detail_small
Evidence that 2012 should be The Year of the Vol
Checkerboard_enzone_small
State Of The Class: A List Of Tennessee's 2012 Recruits - UPDATED
A_cullen_the_bug_small
Where Do We Go From Here with Stokes?
A_cullen_the_bug_small
Joe Paterno Near Death?
Picture_081_small
Ob-la-di, Ob-la-da
Small
Shanks , Kirven, Brown. Ut Outlook
Tn_small
Tommy Spangler

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SHOP THE ROCKY TOP TALK STORE

Gameday Depot University Apparel

Animated Drive Charts

RTT Classics

RTT Classics 2008 Animated BlogPoll2007 Animated BlogPollLOL! Your logo is so scary! Welcome to Rocky Top Talk Tradition! Fiddlin' on the Roof2008 Animated BlogPoll The Season of Which We Do Not Speak Pearlfection Case Study: 2QB Systems and the 2005 Tennessee Volunteers The 2007 College Football Blogger Awards The 2006 College Football Blogger Awards The 20 coolest college football logos The 10 worst college football logos The 29 most boring college football logos 2006 Animated BCS Race 2005 Animated Race to the Rose Bowl

FanShots

Quick hits of video, photos, quotes, chats, links and lists that you find around the web.

Recent FanShots

Softball - #9 Tennessee defeats #1 Arizona State 3-0 in Tempe
#9 Lady Vols softball opens the season in the Kajikawa Classic
Peyton Manning's face is everywhere!!
Potential Alzheimer's treatment with results.
Volunteer baseball TV schedule announced
Feelslike98 Film Room
Your 2012 University of Tennessee Volunteers Recruiting Class
USA Today Pre-season Coach's baseball poll
Cordarrelle Patterson Signs With Tennessee
Game recap

+ New FanShot All FanShots >

YouTube


Editor-in-Chief

Gameday_depot_hat_guy_190x190__no_drop_shadow__small Joel Hollingsworth

Senior Editor

Gromit_small David Hooper

Associated_20press_clayliston_1965_l_small kidbourbon

Tennessee_logo_small Will Shelton

Tumblr_lx1hpdd3yx1r2a42bo1_250_small Chris Pendley

Mutantenemy_small Incipient_Senescence

Ut_small Brad Shepard

Author

Avatar2_small rustytanton

Vols_dooley_hair_small Getoffmyvols

Pygmy_marmoset_small marmotman

Picture_081_small Joseph Stanley

Jackson_the_mule_avatar_small Jackson the Mule

Img_0171_small RockyTopinKY

6156218740_03c5ca84f5_m_small VolnVA

Top_small _trey_

Small Chien Rouge